View Full Version : Has anyone else read the manga?
Well? I've only read it. I would like to see the anime. but I like the style in the manga a little more. Is it any good?
Ko Hakaisha
18-04-01, 03:22 PM
The anime is excellent. ^^ I highly recommend it, especially if you liked the manga.
EVA fiend
18-04-01, 03:26 PM
I've read vols 1-14 of the manga, & it's very funny, but I've only seen a small part of the anime series, so I can't give you a camparison really...,
My complaints about the manga series are that it can be quite repetitive & tedious in places, & Viz Communication is taking too long in publishing them..., :D
I've read the mangas and seen the movies, but I think the mangas are better!
But maybe the series is better! :)
Yoshi-chan
18-04-01, 08:29 PM
its cool!
Ko Hakaisha
18-04-01, 10:12 PM
Well, I've only read volumes 1-7 and 10, so I'm not as well-read as Eva fiend, but I'm much more well-watched. ^^ I'd say they are equally good, because they each have little one ep/issue things that are incredibly funny but don't change the plot ... You should really go for both. ^^
Asuza_chan
19-04-01, 04:30 PM
The manga is better, even though the anime was great. The thing is, after the first season Takahashi-samma lost creative control so the animation for the series just totally went to ----. the OAV's and movies do have much nicer animation, but they don't go along with the manga. I'd say get everything Ranma :p
7thKeeper
19-04-01, 06:07 PM
Heh.. I agree with Asuza-chan on the get all Ranma part.. I haven't been able to get any of the anime *mutters evil curses about anime not being brought into Finland* but I do have volumes 1-17 of the manga.. :) and I love them...
Ko Hakaisha
19-04-01, 06:59 PM
Well, you're lucky on one account. ^^ We've only had up to volume 15 released in the USA. :(
Asuza_chan
19-04-01, 07:56 PM
Yeah, Viz is slow and stupid and they charge too much money for two measly episodes. I just record Ranma off Mexican TV :lol:
Ko Hakaisha
19-04-01, 11:46 PM
And you're lucky they air it there!! ^^
Mika-chan
19-04-01, 11:47 PM
I like the manga, but I think some things in the series are funnier when you watch it animated!
Originally posted by Ko Hakaisha
Well, you're lucky on one account. ^^ We've only had up to volume 15 released in the USA. :(
15? I'm up to 17 here. and its the Viz graphic Novels
The Manga's definitely better, but the TV series is good on account of its being in COLOR...
7thKeeper
20-04-01, 07:41 PM
hmm? Viz has done translation till volume 17. I'd be expecting 18 by summer. Just a hunch...
Falinah
23-04-01, 11:17 PM
I really liked the anime, but the comics were almost better. I have quite a few of the japanese and some of the one's still to come out are really cool. Unfortunately they don't have Akari-chan in the anime (although it'd be a shame to know that there was a dubbed version of her) she's a really cool character! The movies are pretty cool though.
sorata_chan
24-04-01, 12:41 AM
That's how I found out about Ranma, manga's better the anime is too short and doesn't explain much, dubbing is BAD specially on Ranma, well, it's JUST ranma
Originally posted by Ko Hakaisha
Well, you're lucky on one account. ^^ We've only had up to volume 15 released in the USA. :(
Heheh, I got tired of waiting for the translations ... ended up locating some scanned Japanese Ranma 1/2 manga :)
(and yes, I'm still purchasing the graphic novels as they come out, even though I've already read 'em, that's part of the fansub ethic ;))
The manga is better than the series, but both are really great :) Can't go wrong with Ranma! (I love my Akane winamp skin :D)
I think most of you are referring to the Viz Graphic novels as "manga." manga is a Japanese comic.
I've read 20, 23, 25, 26, 27, 29, 30, 31, 33, ah I can't remember them all 36, I think, of the manga.
I like the anime, I always watch it subbed, too bad Viz messes up the translations so much... and it's too bad that the dubbing is so terrible...
heerogf
05-05-01, 09:26 AM
the manga is sooo hilarious, i recommend the anime if u like it
Killjoy
05-05-01, 11:17 AM
I like the Viz Graphic Novels much better than the anime, but then again, I haven't been able to rent the anime subtitled--so I guess the anime got off to a bad start in my mind (Ranma's voice... ugh). However, the written work seems to be funnier anyway--especially when Soun does his "big head" trick :lol:
Master Ranma
13-01-02, 12:09 AM
I read Vol. 1-19 so far! It's great!
My first Manga Vol. was 13! That's how I was hooked into it!
vBulletin® v3.7.4, Copyright ©2000-2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.