PDA

View Full Version : Akira SE DVD Review


Jesmaster
08-08-01, 08:49 PM
I'm surprised... there isn't much discussion about the Akira DVD here, just people saying that they got it. So I guess I'll start things off....

I got the beautiful tin Akira DVD at the mall a week ago and I got to watch it a few days ago so let me put some of my opinions

Video
-----
First of all the video quality is amazing! This is not the old VHS tape I remember seeing! The restoration was a complete success and despite being over a decade old this movie wows me in terms of animation and detail then even some of the better stuff released now.
A definite show-off disc, probably one of the best Region 1 DVD video transfers other than Princess Mononoke.

Sound
-----
Ah how beautiful it is! First of all Akira's soundtrack just plain rules! It fits the movie so much I can't even describe it. Tetsuo's theme is one of my favorites, being used in nearly all of his psychic rampages, it always fits the scene! Of course, this release on DVD has the sound quality beefed up in all regards, I watched the Japanese version and the sound boomed throw my surround setup! Unfortunately my home theater system does not have DD 5.1 (plan to get it soon though, have to buy a DVD player with a 5.1 decoder) but I know the dub is in 5.1 as well as the menus but even hearing it in normal DD is a treat for the ears. I haven't watched the new dub yet but I may check it out later. I have seen the old dub but do not remember it to compare.

Packaging
---------
Common, could it get any better than this?!? Awsome dark metallic case, opens easily but the discs are a little tough to get out. Gotta push and lift, push and lift. Thats my only minor complaint in this area.

Presentation
------------
These menus simply rock! They are anamorphic and I am 95% sure that they are in DD 5.1. Either way the menus load fast, have cool effects and allow you to easily browse through all the material on the discs.

Extras
------
I BREIFLY checked out the extras disc. I watched a few of the movie/TV trailers and commercials, they are subbed and are really neat. There is a HUGE glossary of terms used in the movie with detailed explinations. There is a 14min piece on the restoration of the movie, split into video/sound/new dub. There are also interviews with the dub voice actors and the japanese director(his name escapes me at the moment). There are also over 4000 stills to check out, you can also listen to the soundtrack via buttons skipping to the exact moment in the moive where the soundtrack plays. Also there is a HUGE making of Akira video, it is in japanese and it is subbed. That is all the extras I was able to think of off the top of my head, there may be more that I forgot about. Either way the extras DVD is PACKED!

Content
-------
It has been a long time since I saw Akira on VHS. I really didn't remember too much of the movie but one thing I did remember was that it was kind of confusing. When I popped in this DVD and watched the subbed version, the translation was much better and it was so much easier to understand what was going on! I enjoyed the moive 100 times more than when I saw it on VHS. This movie is jammed packed action, mystery, politics and everything else that makes a movie enjoyable and deep. The setting for one is very well done. We are in a world of anarchy and it is potrayed through cult factions, terrorists, biker gangs, secret experiments and many other things. One main meaning of this movie that I find intriguing is what happens when those who are picked on obtain great power, we see this through Tetsuo who admires his friend Kaneda but always ends up being rescued by him and begins to hate him for that. Things get very interesting when Tetsuo starts to come in to power... no matter how much changes, some things stay the same. Due to spoilers I leave it at that.

Overall
-------
One of, if not the best Region 1 DVD release so far. Akira is a classic and should be watched by all anime fans. If you have only seen the old dub of Akira you have NOT seen Akira! This is the best this movie will ever look and sound so I say you should throw down the money to buy this, it is well worth the purchase.

...so says Jesmaster
http://anime.haproductions.com

baragon0
08-08-01, 08:52 PM
Originally posted by Jesmaster


I got the beautiful tin Akira DVD at the mall a week ago and I got to watch it a few days ago so let me put some of my opinions


I got two of them :dodgy:

One for safe keeping (collectors item) the other for personal entertainment :D

mrgazpacho
08-08-01, 08:58 PM
Thanks for the review, Jes! :up:

You're new, but already a valuable contributor :D

Drizzten
08-08-01, 09:00 PM
Other threads on the restored Akira:

Akira Special Edition (http://animeboards.com/t17634/s.html)
Akira Shipped! For me at least (http://animeboards.com/t21693/s.html)
Akira (http://animeboards.com/t22132/s.html)

I agree. The only thing that would have made this Limited Edition DVD better would be including the original English dub. They did a superb job, and I hope other anime DVD masterers take note of how to do a QUALITY DVD job from here on. :up:

jetalone
09-08-01, 09:31 AM
First of all, good review, Jesmaster :D

I might as well post my initial thoughts here, rather than in the other thread...

Despite some stupidity on my part :heh: my Akira SE tin came in the mail today.....I haven't looked at the second disc, due to time restrictions, but I was just blown away by the image quality....it was absolutely amazing, for a relatively old film.....Pioneer did an excellent job.

Originally posted by Drizzten

and I hope other anime DVD masterers take note of how to do a QUALITY DVD job from here on. :up:


Yes! :D

*cough*D&R/EoE *cough*

Well, I hope, anyway...

jetblack
10-08-01, 01:16 AM
I agree... the packaging is incredible except for the choice they made in disc-locking mechanisms. These things are really bad and you practically need a crowbar to pull the disc out. There's really no easy way to get them out. I think I even damaged my disc 2 ... ya know, where the plastic layers pull away from each other near the hole and it looks like a "bubble" appears near the edge.

At any rate, AKIRA rules. Disc two has some really great info on it and the movie itself looks beautiful.

Id0
15-08-01, 04:02 AM
Great review... thanx... i was looking for a good review that would talk me into buying akira DVD... only prob now is.. i need money to buy Akira...! :p

Oh... just a note... i have got it on video now...

P.S i heard somewhere can't remember where... that the new release doesn't have as good voice acting as the original... but the new one has better translation.. did anyone notice this...? Is it true...?

jetalone
15-08-01, 09:11 AM
The translation is definitely better...a lot of thighs are cleared up with this new translation.

Better voice acting...hmm, this is purely subjective, of course....I can't say which dub I prefer, honestly. I have read/heard several people's thoughts on why they prefer the old dub acting, though, but it doesn't trouble me, seeing as I prefer to watch it subtitled, and all...

I'd also like to mention that I found the production report, the restoration, the music vid, and the interview with Katsuhiro Otomo quite informative, and, well, interesting....that glossary provides more than adequate assistance to anybody who's lost on a few of the themes/characters/issues, etc...(who isn't?? :heh: )

I haven't looked through many of the production materials yet, though.....assured that they'll keep me busy for a while, though. :heh:

Edit: Yes, I've noticed that typo...thought I might leave it, though :D

Corsair
16-08-01, 01:29 AM
Good was been debating on to get the special edition tin yet or not :o

Panzer Strike
30-08-01, 02:45 AM
I thought it was pretty good.

20042012
10-10-01, 02:45 AM
i got the SE, loved it, but the gold disks dont play right on my ps2... so those of you with a just a ps2... get the regular re-release.... i also dont plug my ps2 in to the amp so no 5.1 from it.... NOT THAT IT MATTERS.... nm

Drizzten
10-10-01, 03:12 AM
Welcome to Animeboards, 20042012. :wavey:

I have the limited-edition SE tin DVD and both discs play fine on my PS2.

AnkaraStark
29-10-01, 10:34 PM
Originally posted by Jesmaster
I'm surprised... there isn't much discussion about the Akira DVD here, just people saying that they got it. So I guess I'll start things off....

I got the beautiful tin Akira DVD at the mall a week ago and I got to watch it a few days ago so let me put some of my opinions

Video
-----
First of all the video quality is amazing! This is not the old VHS tape I remember seeing! The restoration was a complete success and despite being over a decade old this movie wows me in terms of animation and detail then even some of the better stuff released now.
A definite show-off disc, probably one of the best Region 1 DVD video transfers other than Princess Mononoke.

Sound
-----
Ah how beautiful it is! First of all Akira's soundtrack just plain rules! It fits the movie so much I can't even describe it. Tetsuo's theme is one of my favorites, being used in nearly all of his psychic rampages, it always fits the scene! Of course, this release on DVD has the sound quality beefed up in all regards, I watched the Japanese version and the sound boomed throw my surround setup! Unfortunately my home theater system does not have DD 5.1 (plan to get it soon though, have to buy a DVD player with a 5.1 decoder) but I know the dub is in 5.1 as well as the menus but even hearing it in normal DD is a treat for the ears. I haven't watched the new dub yet but I may check it out later. I have seen the old dub but do not remember it to compare.

Packaging
---------
Common, could it get any better than this?!? Awsome dark metallic case, opens easily but the discs are a little tough to get out. Gotta push and lift, push and lift. Thats my only minor complaint in this area.

Presentation
------------
These menus simply rock! They are anamorphic and I am 95% sure that they are in DD 5.1. Either way the menus load fast, have cool effects and allow you to easily browse through all the material on the discs.

Extras
------
I BREIFLY checked out the extras disc. I watched a few of the movie/TV trailers and commercials, they are subbed and are really neat. There is a HUGE glossary of terms used in the movie with detailed explinations. There is a 14min piece on the restoration of the movie, split into video/sound/new dub. There are also interviews with the dub voice actors and the japanese director(his name escapes me at the moment). There are also over 4000 stills to check out, you can also listen to the soundtrack via buttons skipping to the exact moment in the moive where the soundtrack plays. Also there is a HUGE making of Akira video, it is in japanese and it is subbed. That is all the extras I was able to think of off the top of my head, there may be more that I forgot about. Either way the extras DVD is PACKED!

Content
-------
It has been a long time since I saw Akira on VHS. I really didn't remember too much of the movie but one thing I did remember was that it was kind of confusing. When I popped in this DVD and watched the subbed version, the translation was much better and it was so much easier to understand what was going on! I enjoyed the moive 100 times more than when I saw it on VHS. This movie is jammed packed action, mystery, politics and everything else that makes a movie enjoyable and deep. The setting for one is very well done. We are in a world of anarchy and it is potrayed through cult factions, terrorists, biker gangs, secret experiments and many other things. One main meaning of this movie that I find intriguing is what happens when those who are picked on obtain great power, we see this through Tetsuo who admires his friend Kaneda but always ends up being rescued by him and begins to hate him for that. Things get very interesting when Tetsuo starts to come in to power... no matter how much changes, some things stay the same. Due to spoilers I leave it at that.

Overall
-------
One of, if not the best Region 1 DVD release so far. Akira is a classic and should be watched by all anime fans. If you have only seen the old dub of Akira you have NOT seen Akira! This is the best this movie will ever look and sound so I say you should throw down the money to buy this, it is well worth the purchase.

...so says Jesmaster
http://anime.haproductions.com

Thank you for the information! ^_^

AnkaraStark
29-10-01, 10:35 PM
I can't wait to open my DVD now :heh: ^_^ Very much looking forward to it! :D

Project Akira
07-04-02, 12:09 PM
Originally posted by Jesmaster
There are also interviews with the dub voice actors and the japanese director(his name escapes me at the moment).The director would also be the creator of the manga master cartoonist Katsuhiro Otomo.